Get ready for some serious debate! Would You Rather NFL Questions are about to become your new favorite way to pass the time before, during, and even after the game. These aren’t your grandma’s “Would You Rather” scenarios. We’re talking football-specific dilemmas that will test your loyalty, strategy, and maybe even your sanity.
What are Would You Rather NFL Questions, and Why Do We Love Them?
Would You Rather NFL Questions take the classic “Would You Rather” game and give it a gridiron twist. Instead of choosing between eating broccoli or Brussels sprouts, you’re deciding between winning a Super Bowl with a terrible quarterback or never making the playoffs again but having a Hall of Fame signal-caller. They’re fun, thought-provoking, and designed to spark passionate (and sometimes hilarious) debates among football fans. Their popularity stems from the fact that they tap into our love of hypotheticals and allow us to explore the complexities of the game in a lighthearted way. They are also very popular, because:
- Test your knowledge of the game.
- Force you to think strategically.
- Create a lot of arguments among fans.
These questions are used in a variety of settings. Fans might toss them around at tailgate parties to kill time before the game. Pundits and analysts sometimes use them on sports talk shows to generate buzz and engage with viewers. Fantasy football leagues could even incorporate them as a fun side game to test their members’ football acumen. Here’s a quick look at how they might be used:
- Tailgate entertainment
- Sports talk show segments
- Fantasy football league challenges
Basically, any situation where football fans gather is ripe for a good old “Would You Rather” NFL debate!
Quarterback Quandaries: Would You Rather…?
The quarterback is the most important position in football, so it’s no surprise that many “Would You Rather” scenarios center around them. These questions will force you to consider the value of different quarterback traits and the impact they have on a team.
- Would you rather have a quarterback with a cannon for an arm but questionable accuracy, or one with pinpoint accuracy but a noodle arm?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who’s a scrambling wizard but prone to injuries, or a pocket passer who’s durable but lacks mobility?
- Would you rather have a quarterback with all the physical tools but a terrible attitude, or one with limited physical gifts but an incredible work ethic?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who chokes in big games but is dominant in the regular season, or one who’s clutch in the playoffs but struggles in the regular season?
- Would you rather have a rookie quarterback who shows flashes of brilliance but is inconsistent, or a veteran quarterback who’s reliable but has a limited ceiling?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who is a great leader but average player, or a great player but terrible leader?
- Would you rather have a quarterback with perfect arm strength but very low football IQ, or someone with terrible arm strength but high football IQ?
- Would you rather your QB throws for 5,000 yards with 20 touchdowns but 20 interceptions, or 3,500 yards with 30 touchdowns and 5 interceptions?
- Would you rather your quarterback be a social media sensation, or be a complete recluse who only focuses on football?
- Would you rather be a QB who wins many Super Bowls, but never breaks a single-season record, or break all the single-season records but never win a Super Bowl?
- Would you rather have a coach who always drafts quarterbacks based on stats, or based on personality?
- Would you rather your quarterback be the best at throwing short passes, or throwing long passes?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who is never injured, but is just average, or one who is a superstar but always injured?
- Would you rather draft a QB who is 6'8" and 280 lbs, or 5'10" and 170 lbs?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who’s famous for throwing trick plays, or one who is famous for accuracy?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who can run a 4.3 40-yard dash, or one who can bench press 400 lbs?
- Would you rather a quarterback who is amazing at reading defenses but has a weak arm, or one with a cannon arm who can’t read defenses?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who throws the ball as hard as he can every time, or one who adjusts his throwing to the situation?
- Would you rather your quarterback only run the ball, or only pass the ball?
- Would you rather have a QB who peaked early in their career, or late?
- Would you rather your quarterback be a Christian, or be an atheist?
- Would you rather have a left-handed quarterback, or right-handed?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who makes risky throws, or conservative throws?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who is always stressed and uptight, or always relaxed and carefree?
- Would you rather a quarterback who is extremely spiritual, or extremely scientific?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who never speaks to the media, or one who does it all the time?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who loves playing football more than anything, or one who is in it for the money?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who played for a rival college, or your favorite college?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who goes on to be a politician, or one who coaches football?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who is amazing in practice, or in games?
- Would you rather have a QB who is a good actor, or good singer?
- Would you rather have a quarterback who never smiles, or never frowns?
- Would you rather have a QB that is really into Yoga, or into weight-lifting?
- Would you rather your quarterback own a race horse, or a dog?
- Would you rather your quarterback live in a big city, or country?
Coaching Conundrums: Would You Rather…?
Coaching is crucial in the NFL. These “Would You Rather” questions explore the different philosophies and strategies that coaches employ, and the trade-offs they often face.
- Would you rather have a head coach who’s a brilliant strategist but a terrible motivator, or one who’s an inspirational leader but lacks tactical expertise?
- Would you rather have a head coach who’s known for his offensive genius but neglects the defense, or one who prioritizes defense but struggles to score points?
- Would you rather have a head coach who’s a disciplinarian but alienates players, or one who’s a players’ coach but lacks control?
- Would you rather have a head coach who makes bold, risky decisions that sometimes backfire, or one who plays it safe and rarely takes chances?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is great at drafting, or at trading?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is good at drawing up plays, or calling them live?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is a micromanager, or not involved at all?
- Would you rather a head coach who gets into fights with the other teams, or not show emotion at all?
- Would you rather have a head coach who always kicks a field goal, or goes for it on 4th down?
- Would you rather a head coach who is friends with all the players, or none of them?
- Would you rather your head coach have experience playing football, or just coaching?
- Would you rather have a coach who is always happy, or always angry?
- Would you rather your head coach be a Democrat, or Republican?
- Would you rather your head coach be a genius in football, but dumb in everything else, or vice versa?
- Would you rather have a coach who always blames the players when they lose, or take responsibility himself?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is very arrogant, or very humble?
- Would you rather have a coach who is constantly experimenting, or sticking to the basics?
- Would you rather your coach have a perfect memory, or be very forgetful?
- Would you rather your head coach have a famous wife, or a famous husband?
- Would you rather your head coach spend all his time working, or relaxing?
- Would you rather have a head coach who always wears a suit, or always wears athletic wear?
- Would you rather have a head coach who always gives a motivational speech, or never speaks at all?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is obsessed with winning, or having fun?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is amazing at running a charity, or bad?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is always giving back to the community, or never?
- Would you rather your head coach only eat pizza, or salad?
- Would you rather have a head coach who is very lucky, or skilled?
- Would you rather your head coach live in the city, or countryside?
- Would you rather your head coach have no children, or dozens?
- Would you rather have a head coach who writes poetry, or paints?
- Would you rather have a head coach who always has a good excuse when losing, or a bad one?
- Would you rather have a head coach who wins awards, or not?
- Would you rather your head coach be great at golf, or tennis?
- Would you rather your head coach be a celebrity, or an nobody?
- Would you rather your head coach have a PHD, or never go to college?
Franchise Fortunes: Would You Rather…?
These questions are about building a successful NFL franchise over the long term. They force you to consider the importance of factors like fan base, stadium location, and team history.
- Would you rather own a team with a small but incredibly loyal fan base in a beautiful city, or a team with a massive but fickle fan base in a less desirable location?
- Would you rather own a team with a state-of-the-art stadium but a losing record, or a team with a dilapidated stadium but a winning tradition?
- Would you rather inherit a team with a rich history and multiple championships but an aging roster, or a team with no history but a young, promising core?
- Would you rather own a team that always makes the playoffs but never wins the Super Bowl, or a team that rarely makes the playoffs but wins a Super Bowl every decade?
- Would you rather own a team that is always in the news, or rarely?
- Would you rather own a team that is privately owned, or publicly?
- Would you rather your team be called the “Eagles”, or “Turkeys”?
- Would you rather your team have a cool logo, or a bad one?
- Would you rather your players wear green, or pink?
- Would you rather your team play in a dome, or outdoors?
- Would you rather your team play in a big city, or small town?
- Would you rather your team be very old, or very new?
- Would you rather your stadium serve good food, or bad food?
- Would you rather your cheerleaders be very attractive, or ugly?
- Would you rather your mascot be cool, or uncool?
- Would you rather your stadium have very comfortable seats, or uncomfortable ones?
- Would you rather your stadium be very easy to get to, or hard?
- Would you rather your team be located in a warm place, or cold place?
- Would you rather your team be known for offense, or defense?
- Would you rather your team be located on the West Coast, or East Coast?
- Would you rather your team have a lot of retired numbers, or not many?
- Would you rather your team be famous, or not?
- Would you rather your team always wear throwback jerseys, or new ones?
- Would you rather your team have a large practice facility, or small one?
- Would you rather your team be located near the ocean, or mountains?
- Would you rather your team have a very good owner, or bad one?
- Would you rather your team charge very high ticket prices, or low?
- Would you rather your team be located close to Canada, or Mexico?
- Would you rather your team travel by bus, or airplane?
- Would you rather your team be good at selling merchandise, or not?
- Would you rather the media love your team, or hate them?
- Would you rather your team be known for being very charitable, or not?
- Would you rather your team have a very high payroll, or low?
- Would you rather your stadium have a retractable roof, or not?
- Would you rather your team have a very intense fan base, or laid-back?
So, there you have it – 100 “Would You Rather” NFL questions to get your football brain buzzing! These are just a starting point, of course. Feel free to modify them, create your own, and most importantly, have fun debating the merits of each scenario. Get ready for some heated discussions and maybe even a few friendships tested. After all, that’s what “Would You Rather NFL Questions” are all about!